How to Spot Fake Reviews Before You Buy

A product has 4.8 stars and thousands of reviews. It looks safe. But a rating is only as honest as the reviews behind it.

Since October 21, 2024, a Federal Trade Commission rule has banned fake reviews and lets the agency seek civil penalties of more than $50,000 per violation. The rule helps, but it punishes after the fact. These six checks protect you before you buy.

Key takeaways

• The FTC rule targets sellers, not shoppers. Ordinary reviewers cannot be held liable for what they honestly say.
• Fake reviews are banned, but you still need to check, because enforcement comes after the sale.
• Read the middle ratings first and look for specifics.

What the rule actually bans

The FTC's rule covers these practices by businesses:

• Writing or selling fake reviews and testimonials.
• Paying for reviews that express a particular opinion, positive or negative.
• Reviews by company insiders that hide their connection to the seller.
• Company run sites that claim to be independent.
• Threats or false accusations used to remove negative reviews.
• Fake follower counts and engagement numbers.

In December 2025 the FTC sent warning letters to ten companies about possible violations, which shows the problem still exists.

Six checks to run

1. Read the 2 and 3 star reviews first. Honest mixed reviews describe tradeoffs. Fake ones tend to be all praise or all complaint.

2. Look for specifics. A useful review says how long the person used it, what broke, or what surprised them. "Great product, fast shipping" tells you nothing.

3. Check the dates. A pile of five star reviews posted within a few days, after months of silence, is worth a second look.

4. Check whether reviews match the product. If reviews describe something different from what is listed, or praise an unrelated item, be careful.

5. Look for disclosures. Reviewers who received a free product should say so. If a glowing review hides that, discount it.

6. Confirm with a source the seller does not control. If a review site says it is independent, check its About page for an owner. A seller can run an "independent" site, and the rule bans claiming otherwise.

A quick way to score what you find

Count the red flags from the six checks. This is a rule of thumb, not an official test.

• 0 or 1 flags: the reviews look trustworthy enough to rely on.
• 2 or 3 flags: pause. Look for the same product from another seller or a source you trust more.
• 4 or more flags: skip it, or buy only if returns are easy.

Match your effort to the stakes. For a $12 item you can return, a quick scan is enough. For something expensive, hard to return, or tied to safety, run all six.

If you spot a fake

Report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. Then leave your own honest review after you buy. That is exactly what the rule protects.

Your checklist for this week

• ☐ Before your next purchase over $50, read the 2 and 3 star reviews first.
• ☐ Sort reviews by newest and scan the dates for a sudden burst.
• ☐ Look for one review that names a specific problem or use.
• ☐ Check one source the seller does not own.
• ☐ Save ReportFraud.ftc.gov for when you need it.

The takeaway

A star rating is a claim, not proof. Spend two minutes on the middle reviews and the dates before you buy anything you cannot easily return.

Combine this with the 24 hour rule so urgency does not skip the checks, and use six ways to check a sale for the price side.

Subscribe below for the next Shopping piece: how to read unit prices on a shelf tag.